Miss Cavell was calm and dignifiedAbove: Amy Hodson stands top centre in 1919.

Miss Cavell was calm and dignified

By Monica Kendall (St Hugh’s College, 1973)

At dawn on 12 October 1915, English nurse Edith Cavell was shot at a Brussels rifle range for treason against the German occupying forces. A few hours later, the news had spread to an English schoolgirl who lived near the ‘clinic’ where Miss Cavell had hidden Allied soldiers.

The schoolgirl, Amy Hodson, wrote in her diary that day: ‘Several people who saw Miss Cavell yesterday said that she was perfectly calm and dignified. She has died like a martyr ... Mr de Leval, the Spanish Minister, and the American Minister went last night to the Kommandantur to beg for her release, and they answered “No.”’

The Germans had posted notices about the execution that morning, but the further details can only have spread through word of mouth.

My great-aunt Amy was fourteen. I never met her, as she emigrated to Canada after the war. Her diaries are in exercise books and date from 3 August 1914 to 1920. Some years ago, my mother mentioned to Amy’s widowed son-in-law on the phone that I was interested in our family’s history. On a visit to England he gave me her diaries and some photos.

Miss Cavell was calm and dignified

Managing to decipher her handwriting — eventually even when she lapsed into French — I was fascinated. She writes of the constant gunfire noise, zeppelins, spies in trams, the lack of food. Also intriguing were Amy’s many mentions of a ‘Mrs B’. On 10 October 1915, Amy writes: ‘Met Mrs B.’s children coming back from the Kommandantur, and they said that they spoke of Miss Cavell being shot, and as she has not had half so many Tommy Atkins as Mrs B they are very much frightened of their mother being shot too.’ It is only two days later that Amy feels it safe to name her: Mme Bodart, sentenced to fifteen years’ hard labour. I found that she was born Annie Doherty in Northern Ireland.

I didn’t know what to do with the diaries. For a decade they slumbered in my filing cabinet. Then I saw that the Imperial War Museum was interested in acquiring first-hand accounts. I tentatively emailed them. I thought they might be interested in a faint, fragile, typewritten account by Amy of the start of the war when she was trapped on the Belgian seacoast with her two younger brothers.

I took the tissue-like pages carefully to the museum. I was stunned to be told that the account was ‘exceptionally interesting’ and ‘full of historical value’. I woke up in the middle of night: I had to transcribe and publish her diaries.

Amy’s mentions of Ada Bodart turn out to be hugely important for research into the secret network. In Britain we focus only on the brave Edith Cavell and ignore others involved. At the National Archives I found a fat document of letters between Ada Bodart and the British Government for recompense on her release from a German prison in 1919. On 14 May she wrote: ‘There are four months, since I gave my reports, to the General Lyon, English militaire attaché to the Legation to Bruselles, till this present date. There is not an answer, which I think is very unkind, considering all I have done and suffered in a German Prison, during three years for having kept, fed, clothed and conducted into Holland the English soldiers. The circumstances in I and my two children at present is very sad, as we have lost all. . . . I am Ada Bodart condemned with Miss Cavell, in 1915 as we worked together.’ The Government eventually agreed that she had saved 850 British soldiers, and she was awarded an OBE. She is now mostly forgotten.

Miss Cavell was calm and dignified

But Amy’s diary brings her back to life and I hope it will give her some recognition in this centenary. In Amy’s diary of 11 May 1915, she writes: ‘Mrs B.’s house is again being spied on. The Belgians round about her house have given her away. Four more English soldiers came to her this morning. They are all in a terrible funk each time a bell rings. If a suspicious-looking person rings they scramble up two ladders that are at the end of the garden.’

Did Amy want her diaries published? She took them to Canada with her and they survived many changes of home. Amy writes on 20 July 1915: ‘I have written a long story about my experience during the bombardment of Middelkerke, and am going to write them in books and sell them.’ That account is now in a published book: and sold in a bookshop in Brussels. I hope she would be pleased.

Monica Kendall’s ‘Miss Cavell Was Shot’: The Diaries of Amy Hodson, 1914–1920 is published by SilverWood Books. She is speaking at The Forum, Norwich, on 7 October and Waterstones Brussels on 9 October.

Archive and diary images and author photo are all © Monica Kendall, reproduced with permission. Book jacket © Silverwood Books.


By Dr. Gabriel A. Sivan

There was much talk of German "frightfulness" during World War I, which was often dismissed as Allied propaganda. The fate of Nurse Edith Cavell shows that the charge was sometimes justified.
In my view, a precedent was created for the Lidice and Oradour atrocities during World War II, for the wholesale destruction of civilian populations in Nazi-occupied Europe, and for the killing of Allied POWs who tried to escape from their captors (as in the Malmedy massacre). These war crimes were committed by some elements of the Wehrmacht as well as by the SS and the Gestapo.

By Jane Wyatt (Cor...

My grandmother, Stella Shepherd, was a similar age in to Amy, living in Brussels at the time of Edith Cavell's death. The family she lived with were involved in Nurse Cavell's network, and because her English was good, she helped to brief the servicemen before their escape (through a rather small grille, which caused problems if they had injuries). I think the particular part of the network that she was involved in remained secret, as my mother hasn't found a reference to it in the accounts she's read of Edith Cavell.

I'm glad to hear that the Imperial War Museum might be interested to hear about first hand accounts - my mother has a recording of Stella speaking about her time in Brussels during the war, and the day of Edith Cavell's death.

By Monica Kendall

Jane Wyatt's comment is fascinating about her grandmother: It would be great it you could transcribe the recording and put down all the details you know about your grandmother's time in Brussels. Was she staying with relations? Was she working there, e.g. a maid? I'm sure the IWM would be really interested: just email them.

By Denise Brady

You are one of 3 people who have found information on Ada Bodart this year. I know about her as she was a first cousin of my mother though my mother never met her. Ada Bodart was a great deal older than my mother. Even her daughter Hilda a was older than my mother. I am grateful others have researched her - I met her daughter Hilda once and had a wonderful day with her in Brussels in the sixties.

By Saar

I came to this site after I was archiving a belgium bekanntmachung notice about the sentences of Miss Cavell, Ada Bodart and others. Contact me if you would like this file!

By John Davidson

A personal message to Monica...

I am Amy's Grandson, son of her daughter Miriam and nephew of her sister Joy.

I guess we are related to you. We have been working on one of Amy's books for two months. On
December 18th, I was researching the word "Crocodile" and accidentally discovered your book!

I will be surprising my family tonight with this discovery... they will be thrilled.

Would like to be in contact with you.