Tokyo: it’s hard for Japanese women to break out but gender relations are evolving nonetheless
By Richard Lofthouse
A terrific volume from Oxford University Press, Japan and the Shackles of the Past is by R Taggart Murphy, a professor of international political economy at the University of Tsukuba in Tokyo who has lived most of his life in Japan. Inspired by Oscar Wilde’s jibe — that ‘the whole of Japan is a pure invention: there is no such country; there are no such people’ — we thought we’d draw out some of Taggart Murphy’s numerous points about a country that is still — we might contend — mostly misunderstood by the west.
1. Kyoto is beautiful.
No it isn’t. Particular temples and other sites are exquisite, as any tourist will attest, but the city ‘resembles a once-lovely woman who has had acid thrown in her face; you can still make out enough to tell that she had been a great beauty, but it is a melancholy act of mental reconstruction’.
2. ‘Abenomics’ (after Prime Minister Abe Shinzo’s use of fiscal policy to devalue the yen and jolt Japan out of deflation) makes him recognizably ‘western’.
No it doesn’t. Rather, it is a case of reaction parading as reform. Shinzo’s a hard-right-winger who wanted to give Japan a fiscal ‘sugar-high,’ to achieve the political aim of wresting control of the upper house, duly achieved in 2013. His real goal is to take Japan back to the 1930s, repealing everything that was good and right about the American-sponsored constitution that was handed to Japan after 1945, such as the notion of popular sovereignty and gender equality.
3. The Meiji Restoration in 1868 was the defining moment in Japanese history.
No it wasn’t. That’s the result of western navel gazing. The real date of consequence was the establishment of the Tokugawa Shogunate in 1603, which created the very institutions that survived 1868 and were later disastrous for Japan.
Second bite of the cherry? Japan's economy has returned to inflation since current PM Abe Shinzo devalued the yen
4. Japan is now irrelevant except as a strategic asset.
Not unless viewed shallowly from Wall Street. Japan is the world’s third-largest economy and remains a leading manufacturer, as was demonstrated in March 2011, when the disruptive effect of the tsunami on global supply chains was far more serious than onlookers imagined it to be. As for security, Japan remains of paramount importance to America, yet its own pursuit of territorial claims (the Senkaku Islands) get tangled up in the West’s relationship to Beijing.
5. Japan is a shining example of a polity where religion doesn’t upset the temporal order
Absolutely wrong. Even the divine right of kings allowed for a transcendent power greater than royalty, whereas in Japan the concept of the divine is embodied in the emperor, who is considered to be actually divine, thus rendering political protest uniquely difficult. This is why Japan suffers a deep spiritual crisis today, because since the emperor’s role became muted after 1945, no one knows what to believe in. It’s a turbulent problem that might again be rendered as nationalism in the face of Chinese provocation – a real worry.
6. Japan’s businesses largely lost their mojo after the collapse of the 1980s bubble — since when did Sony do anything interesting?
Wrong again. It’s just that the big winners in Japan are not consumer-facing brands like Apple and Samsung. The three most profitable companies in Japan today are Keyence, Fanuc and Hirose Electric. If you haven’t heard of them, it’s because you’re stuck in your own Sony Walkman time warp.
7. Japan before 1868 was isolated. After 1868 it ‘turned to the west’.
More western navel gazing, and plenty of Japanese wishful thinking. Actually, most of Japan as we know it was influenced historically by China, via Korea. European missionaries entered the country in the 16th century and were later repelled, but not before they won some converts who continued after their departure. Long before Zen Buddhism arrived, Mahayana Buddhism came to Japan via Korea, via China, via the ancient kingdom of Bactria in what is now northern Afghanistan.
Japan is an economic tiger laid low by twenty years of deflation — but that might be changing
8. Japan lost World War Two
Well now you really are parading your ignorance. Japan never referred to it as ‘World War Two’. They referred to it as the Pacific War, to distinguish it from their invasion of mainland China in 1937. In fact they ‘won’ that much larger land campaign in the Ichigo offensive of 1944, beating the Chinese Nationalists. But it was one of the greatest 20th-century examples of unintended consequence. It was not the Japanese who walked into the resulting power vacuum, as planned, but the Communists. As Zhou Enlai put it, without the Japanese, there ‘would have been no new China’.
9. Women have always played a subordinate role in Japan
Not if we allow for the fact that the world’s first novel, The Tale of Genji, was authored by a woman, as was The Pillow Book. ‘Indeed, as a body of writing, Heian’s (794-1185) is unique in world history in that virtually all of it that matters was composed by women.’
10. Japan is gradually becoming more western
Arguably the reverse is true. The rest of the world is becoming more Japanese. Ruling elites are everywhere ‘learning to live with the constant presence of contradiction while perfecting the mental gymnastics necessary to deceive oneself about motive while still acting on that motive.’
- R Taggart Murphy’s Japan and the Shackles of the Past is published by OUP (2014).
All images © Richard Lofthouse.